Seychelles FlagMAMR, Seychelles

Crushed Coral Waste

REPORT ON A TRIAL TO DETERMINE THE LIMING

POTENTIAL OF CRUSHED CORAL WASTE COMPARED TO DOLOMITE

 Jose Loustau-Lalanne

SUMMARY

 

Many farmers in Seychelles cultivate the acidic red soil which is a tropical laterite.

pH ranges from 4.3 - 6.5 and many areas, especially those subject to erosion where low pH is a limiting factor would benefit from the application of cheap agricultural lime.

Presently farmers apply dolomite and also guano to correct soils where a low pH is detrimental to plant growth (Guano being extracted from alkaline calcareous soils has liming potential). Dolomite sales for 1997 was around 2 tons (Source M.A.M.R). Most farmers apply dolomite as a soil ameliorant, that is to induce flocculation in clay soils and render it more manageable rather than for its liming properties.

Liming an acidic soil means that the farmer can grow a wider range of crops, phosphorus availability is improved, nitrification is stimulated, cation exchange capacity is increased, the soil structure is rendered more friable and changes in pH promotes nitrogen fixation in leguminous plants. Over liming however reduces potassium availability and also many micro nutrients. (Efficient fertilizer use in acidic upland soils of the humid tropics - F.A.O Fertilizer and Plant Nutrition Bulletin, 10 by H.R. Von Vexkull).

 

The trial had as the main aim and objective to compare the liming potential of a locally available by product, coral waste to dolomite, an imported item being retailed at Agricultural Requisite Stores. pH was gauged over time in the various sampling sites which had received increasing amounts of both dolomite and coral waste.

Results indicate a higher liming potential for the coral waste at a rate of 1500 Kg/ha and also has a prolonged liming effect at higher rates of application (2000 Kg/ha).

 

INTRODUCTION

 

The United Concrete Products Seychelles (UCPS) has a vast stock of crushed coral waste which is a by-product after the dredged up coral has been washed and sieved. The sand is sold to the public for construction works and the coral waste is stockpiled.

 

Laboratory analysis of this coral waste indicates that it has potential as a liming agent for the acidic ferralsols. (Table 1) The coral waste has 0% salinity as it has been stockpiled for over 10 years and most salts have been leached.

 

MATERIALS AND METHOD

 

The trial plot was at Beoliere, a site on the Research Farm with a slightly acid soil with a high gravel content. Ideally an acid soil of 5.0 would have been ideal but in this instance pH ranged from 5.9 - 6.4 and the plot was the only one available at the time of the trial.

 

The trial was a Randomised Complete Block Resign (RCBD) with 4 replicates for each treatment. Treatment for both dolomite and calcium carbonate were 0, 500, 1000, 1500, 2000 Kg/ha.

 

Each replicate was 1 m2, which meant that each treatment received 0, 50, 100, 150, 200 gms/ m2 of either dolomite or calcium carbonate.

 

The coral waste when stockpiled is in the form of a heavy sledge. A sample was air dried, passed through a grinder and a fine powder like material was seived.

 

Dolomite was bought from the requisite stores and has a more granular texture.

 

40 soil samples were taken in each replicate at the start of the trial and the average pH recorded for each treatment. Every week after, pH was again tested to gauge the liming potential and changes in pH of both Calcium Carbonate and dolomite treated plots.

 

Rainfall was also recorded over the trial period to see whether a certain rainfall pattern has an influence on the liming capacity and to what extent the liming ability is reduced.

Results and Discussions

 

1.4 Laboratory Analysis

 

Table 1: Granulometric analysis of the coral waste 

 

SEIVE OPENING (mm)

 

MATERIAL SEIVED (%)

 

0.25

 

29.0

 

0.08

 

29.5

 

0.0029

 

7.0

 

0.0017

 

34.5

Results of preliminary laboratory analysis gave the following; all of the ground

material passed though a 1mm seive, 29% is in the 0.25mm range 29.5% is in the

0.08mm range,7% is in the 0.0029mm range and 34.5% is in the 0.0017mm

range.

 

This compares favourably with the specifications in the United States for liming material, where 90% should passed through a 1.9mm seive, 50% through a 0.35mm seive and 25% through a 0.14mm seive. (Jones, 1982)

This fine powder-like material can quickly saturate exchange sites and its capacity to alter the pH is greater than dolomite which has more of a granular handling characteristic. (See graph 1 & graph 2).

The coral waste has a pH of 9 (1:2.5 H20), salinity of 0% and conductivity of 120 m mHos/cm. The material tends to be cement like when wet which gives it inferior handling characteristics.

 

TABLE 2: LEACHABLE NUTRIENTS (Mg/Kg) IN THE CALCIUM CARBONATE SAMPLE

 

Magnesium (Mg) Iron (Fe) Copper (Cu) Manganese (Mn)

11.13 0.82 0.003 0.012

 

(Hydrochloric and Nitric acid digestions)

 

TABLE 3: AVERAGE pH CHANGES OVER TIME IN PLOTS TREATED WITH DOLOMITE

Treatment kg/ha week0 week1 week2 week3
0 6.5 6.0 6.1 6.0
500 6.2 6.6 6.6 6.0
1000 6.1 6.4 7.0 6.6
1500 5.9 6.6 6.7 6.5
2000 6.0 6.8 6.7 6.5

 

TABLE 4: AVERAGE pH CHANGES OVER TIME IN PLOTS TREATED WITH CALCIUM CARBONATE

Treatment kg/ha week0 week1 week2 week3
0 6.1 5.9 6.1 6.2
500 6.3 6.9 6.7 6.8
1000 5.9 7.4 7.4 7.05
1500 6.0 7.7 7.4 7.4
2000 6.4 7.7 7.5 7.6

 Results indicate that Calcium Carbonate changes the pH more drastically than dolomite. At 1500 kg/ha Calcium Carbonate changes from pH 6.0 to pH 7.7 whereas dolomite at the same rate changes it to only 6.6 from an original pH of 5.9. 

The higher rates of liming (1500 & 2000 kg/ha) tend to have a prolonged liming effect compared to dolomite which tends to decrease in the 3rd week.

Rainfall certainly contributed to both Calcium Carbonate and dolomite loosing their liming ability but calcium carbonate at 2000kg/ha stabilised at the range of 7.7 – 7.6

CONCLUSION

 It can be stated that Calcium Carbonate has a higher liming potential than dolomite, though it does not provide sufficient magnesium to the soil as opposed to dolomite and has inferior handling characteristics in its ‘natural’ state. It will have to be processed, that is dried and seived before it can be used as a lime. It will be interesting to note costs involved to produce 1 kg of coral waste as a liming agent compared to Dolomite which presently retails at SR 1.10/kg.

Other trials will have to follow to determine whether at the higher rates of liming, Calcium Carbonate has any adverse effect on plant growth and its ability to fix nutrients like phosphorus.

January 1999

 

 

Back to General Information Page
MAMR Home Page